Financing Changes Effective November 20, 2023 for Owner Occupied Multifamily
Cory Carlson

October 6, 2023

Fannie Mae's New Owner-Occupied Financing Changes for Multifamily Properties: Effective November 18, 2023

On November 18, 2023, Fannie Mae is set to implement significant changes in its owner-occupied financing guidelines for multifamily (2-4 unit) properties. These changes are aimed at fostering responsible and sustainable homeownership while also addressing the unique challenges of multifamily housing. Previously, owner occupied buyers using conventional financing to acquire a duplex required 15% down and for triplex and fourplexes 25% down. The change coming allows buyers using conventional financing to put 5% down on 2-4 unit properties that they intend to occupy. This financing type has its benefits when compared to FHA.


FHA financing usually has higher private mortgage insurance (PMI) costs that stick with them for the life of the loan. Conventional PMI is usually less costly and has a clause allowing it to drop once a property has reached a certain equity position.


To monitor compliance with the new owner-occupancy requirements, Fannie Mae will introduce more robust reporting mechanisms. Property owners will be required to provide regular updates on the owner-occupancy status of their multifamily units. Failure to meet these reporting requirements could lead to financial penalties or even the revocation of Fannie Mae financing. This comes as no surprise as being a landlord is no easy task, especially in our Oregon market given the tenant/landlord laws in place. These measures are intended to ensure that property owners adhere to the new guidelines and maintain the required level of owner-occupancy.


Unknown to me at this time are the potential for stricter borrower qualifications and potential for homeowner/investors to meet higher eligibility criteria. Historically owner occupied multifamily buyers could utilize the income from adjoining units to help boost pre-qualification amounts. Called phantom income, the lender would allow 75% of the current rents in place as income for the borrower. Vacant units would be left to the appraiser to determine market rents and that income would help push the buyers maximum loan amounts up.


Fannie Mae's new owner-occupancy financing changes for multifamily properties, set to take effect on November 18, 2023, represent a significant shift in its approach to multifamily housing. By raising the minimum owner-occupancy requirement, tightening borrower eligibility criteria, and implementing stricter reporting and compliance measures, Fannie Mae aims to strike a balance between rental housing and homeownership.


These changes are intended to promote responsible homeownership, improve property stability, and provide aspiring homeowners with greater access to affordable housing options. However, they may also present challenges for investors who rely on rental income from multifamily properties. I suspect with the added allure to house hacking (bigger pockets coined term for "owner occupied") there will be increased competition in the 2-4 unit space, where valuations are already convoluted between comparable sales and the income-approach.


As these changes come into effect, it will be essential for property owners, investors, and prospective homeowners to carefully assess their implications and adapt their strategies accordingly. Ultimately, Fannie Mae's goal is to create a multifamily housing market that offers both rental and homeownership opportunities while promoting responsible and sustainable housing practices.


By Cory Carlson March 12, 2025
Maximizing Profits with Constant Commercial Real Estate’s List-Back Services
By Cory Carlson March 12, 2025
Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs) have gained significant popularity among real estate investors, particularly those looking to defer capital gains taxes while maintaining passive income from real estate holdings. A DST is a legal entity that allows multiple investors to own fractional interests in high-quality, institutional-grade properties. It provides a hands-off approach to real estate investment while offering potential tax advantages under the IRS 1031 Exchange guidelines. This article will explore the profile of an ideal DST investor, the tax treatment of these investments, a step-by-step guide on how to execute a DST exchange, and the critical role of an experienced real estate broker in facilitating the transaction. Who Should Consider a Delaware Statutory Trust? DSTs are not a one-size-fits-all investment. They are best suited for a specific type of investor, typically those who: Are Nearing Retirement or Seeking Passive Income: Investors who want to step away from active property management but still earn rental income find DSTs an attractive option. Have Highly Appreciated Investment Properties: Those looking to sell a property that has appreciated significantly and want to defer capital gains taxes through a 1031 Exchange. Seek Portfolio Diversification: DSTs offer access to diversified, professionally managed commercial properties, including multifamily apartments, medical offices, retail centers, and industrial facilities. Want to Avoid the Hassles of Property Management: DSTs eliminate the burden of dealing with tenants, repairs, and ongoing property oversight. Are Looking for Predictable Income: Many DSTs offer stable, projected distributions, making them an appealing choice for income-focused investors. Have a Low Risk Tolerance for Real Estate Investments: Institutional-grade properties with professional management often provide a more secure, stable investment compared to direct ownership of real estate. Tax Treatment of DSTs One of the main attractions of investing in a DST is the ability to defer capital gains taxes via a 1031 Exchange. Here’s how DSTs are treated from a tax perspective: 1031 Exchange Eligibility: The IRS recognizes DST interests as “like-kind” property, meaning investors can exchange their real estate holdings into a DST without triggering immediate tax liability. Tax Deferral: By utilizing a 1031 Exchange, investors can defer capital gains, depreciation recapture, and state taxes on the sale of a relinquished property. Potential for Step-Up in Basis: Upon the investor’s passing, heirs can receive a step-up in basis, potentially eliminating deferred taxes altogether. Depreciation Benefits: Investors receive depreciation pass-through benefits, which can offset taxable income from distributions. Passive Income Taxation: Income generated from the DST is reported on Schedule E, and depreciation deductions may help reduce taxable income. How to Execute a DST 1031 Exchange A 1031 Exchange into a DST follows a structured process. Below is a step-by-step guide: Step 1: Sell the Relinquished Property The first step is to sell the property that you intend to exchange. The sale proceeds must be handled by a Qualified Intermediary (QI) to maintain 1031 Exchange compliance. Do NOT list the real estate until you have FIRST communicated with a QI. Step 2: Identify the DST Investment Within 45 days of selling the relinquished property, you must identify potential replacement properties. Investors typically work with a an experienced real estate broker specializing in DSTs and 1031 exchanges to review available options. Step 3: Conduct Due Diligence Before committing to a DST investment, it’s crucial to analyze: The quality and location of the underlying real estate. The financial strength and reputation of the DST sponsor. The projected income and risk factors. The loan structure, if any. Step 4: Work with a Qualified Intermediary (QI) The QI facilitates the transaction, ensuring the funds are properly transferred and that all IRS regulations are met. The investor never takes possession of the sales proceeds directly from the relinquished properties. A QI needs to be involved early in the engagement to ensure title and escrow is set up to remain compliant. Step 5: Close on the DST Investment Once the due diligence is complete and the paperwork is finalized, the investor formally acquires a fractional interest in the DST property. The transaction must be completed within 180 days from the sale of the relinquished real estate. Constant Commercial Real Estate can assist in multiple property dispositions if it pertains. Step 6: Receive Passive Income and Tax Benefits After the exchange is finalized, the investor begins receiving distributions, typically on a monthly or quarterly basis. They also continue to defer taxes as long as they remain invested in the DST. Why an Experienced Real Estate Broker is Essential A real estate broker with experience in DSTs plays a vital role in ensuring a smooth and successful exchange. Here’s why their expertise matters: Navigating the Complexity of 1031 Exchanges: A broker familiar with 1031 rules helps investors avoid costly mistakes that could disqualify their tax deferral benefits. Access to Institutional-Quality DST Offerings: Brokers have relationships with reputable DST sponsors, giving investors access to high-quality properties not easily found on the open market. Objective Investment Guidance: An experienced broker helps evaluate DST options, considering factors such as market trends, sponsor track record, and risk assessment. Tailored Investment Strategy: Brokers work with investors to align their DST choices with long-term financial goals, ensuring a suitable fit for their portfolio. Streamlining the Identification Process: Given the strict 45-day identification window, a broker can expedite the selection process, helping investors make informed decisions under time constraints. Compliance with IRS Regulations: Working with a knowledgeable broker reduces the risk of missteps that could jeopardize the exchange. Conclusion Delaware Statutory Trusts provide a compelling investment vehicle for real estate owners seeking tax deferral, passive income, and diversification. However, executing a 1031 Exchange into a DST requires careful planning, thorough due diligence, and strict adherence to IRS rules. For investors looking to transition from active property management to a passive investment structure while preserving wealth, DSTs can be an excellent solution. Engaging an experienced real estate broker is key to identifying quality DST opportunities, navigating the 1031 Exchange process, and ensuring compliance with all regulatory requirements. With the right guidance, investors can leverage DSTs to optimize their real estate portfolios while enjoying long-term financial benefits.
Share by: